QUOTE (Gary Og @ Oct 22 2005, 01:48 AM)
Downloading from Kazaa in Canada may be legal a chara, but no matter what type of spin you put on it, it is still imho a breech of copyright,which is an illegal act. Not necessarily because it costs me money, it's not exactly lots btw, but simply because it is an infringement of the rights of the songwriter, which again, isn't me.
Part of the reason we have so many debates about who wrote what songs, is that very few people get access to the original material which usually credit the original songwriter. On this very thread we have an example of someone who doesn't know the difference between Eire Og and The Wolfetones. Apart from about 40 years, and a completley different birthplace, I would think both bands sound completely different. These mistakes are mainly due to the amount of sub standard, incorrect and innacurate songs available on these sites. The amount of times people have argued about which songs I've recorded, insisting I sing certain songs, which I don't, simply because they downloaded it and therefore assume it must be accurate.
I think it is important that people get the credit they deserve for the songs they have written, and also get the monies that they are due. They afterall took the time to learn to play and write and compose these songs. Individuals such as Paddy McGuigan and Gerry O'Glaican do not get the credit they deserve for the songs they've written, and certainly don't get the financial rewards they are due in this day and age of downloading. This is the big problem. You are getting FREE access to someone elses work.
Personally I am not completely against sharing music,I, however, did not write them, so, when you are passing around details from my cd's which contain songs by other people that I am legally bound to protect their copyright, then I must then ask the admin to discourage these links, and to discourage in general, this type of behaviour on the site altogether. To show that I am not just trying to stop you downloading my cd's, I will send you a cd free of charge a chara if you pm me. A cd on which the copyright has been acknowledged, and that the artists featured will get paid fairly. Is this a compromise?
All the best
Gary Og
Hi
Just registered on this forum, whilst searching for the lyrics of 'Sea around us', and I must both agree and disagree with Gary on this one. The copyright issue is well open for debate and I for one hardly ever think of the consequences of downloading music for free. However, in relation to Irish music, be it traditional, folk or rebel, it is extremely hard to find certain songs by certain artists. For example, tonight I was thinking about The Sea Around Us by the Dubs and how it's been a few years since I heard this song, so I went on to Shareaza and had a look for it. Unsuccessful, I then had a look on Amazon and spent over �30 on several CD's by the Dubs and Clancy Bros. The CD with 'The Sea Around Us' had quite a few other songs on it, but I have at least two exact copies of each of the other songs. I have nearly 20 Dubliners albums, and the majority of the songs appear on every one. It's ridiculous that I paid �10 for a CD that I already had twice over with the exception of one song. The total price for these albums must be at least �150.
We are starting to move forward now with legal downloads, but these companies are trying to dominate the market, and so the songs you download cannot be placed onto CD. They either have to be played on your computer or Ipod, or whatever other Mp3 player that company happens to endorse. With this problem and the paying through the nose for an album in which you only want one song I generally save my money and just download it for free (If I can find it that is).
Now... I do understand what Gary is saying about individual artists not getting the credit they deserve for the songs they have written, because Paddy McGuigan is my uncle and I have the job of opening his royalty letters every month, and granted, the money is pittence. Now and again he'll get a few quid which will take him and the wife out for a few nights, and maybe go towards a holiday, but the majority of the time I reckon it actually costs more to send the envelope! I have also spoken to Paddy about the issue of illegal downloads, and as you can imagine he isn't best pleased about people illegally downloading his music.
The point I made to him was that if people are downloading the odd rebel song for free then maybe they'll go and buy a few rebel albums if they want a particular song. I personally never gave the Clancy Bros much notice until I downloaded a song called 'Red Haired Mary'. I now have five or six albums (real ones, not downloads) by the Clancy Bros. Mind you, he still didn't see my point, but I do see his.
If I was Paddy, or even Gary Og, I would be disgusted at the thought of someone stealing my songs or downloading my albums for free. But there's two sides to every coin... the person downloading is getting the music for free, and if they are thinking about copyright then it will probably be thoughts of getting one over on the big record labels. If they are sharing the music then they are also promoting it. There will eventually be a compromise where music can be legally downloaded at a small cost with no restrictions.
I just hope that Irish music can benifit as a result of this. Although they're not my cup of tea, no offence intended here (I'm more into the Dubs and that generation etc), the Wolfetones and Eire Og are two of the very very few who have kept Irish rebel music alive around the world. None of my mates would be able to sing the version of 'Bring them home' from the B side of my uncles album, but they'd probably be able to recall the version on Eire Og Live at the Brazen Head! (Memories springing up of when I was about 16 sitting outside on a cold winters night with my bottle of Buckfast singing along to that album!). They wouldn't have a clue who the Barleycorn are, or Wolfhound and Ray McArevey, or even the DCR... but they all know the Wolfetones and Eire Og.
The fact of the matter is, these artists are never going to make millions for the songs they wrote in the 60's, 70's and 80's. If you can promote Irish music by sharing it, then it's gotta be a good thing is it not? The music is dying a very undeserved death at the moment imho (please correct me if I'm wrong)... I recently went to the Legends of Irish Folk Concert in Dublin, and myself and the g/f were the youngest there (I'm 26). If we hadn't been there, Laim Clancy would probably have been the youngest! My girlfriend was embarassed and swore she would never go to another Irish Concert with me again LOL. She told me if anyone asked I had to say we were with our grandparents! I personally couldn't have give a flying fiddlers, but it was extremely sad to see a lack of young people present to hear the legends sing songs that actually have some meaning, and not the constant thump thump thump of DJ Teisto and Gatecrasher and the other shite going about these days.
One last thing... I'm sort of with Gary on this one too... I feel for the person who cannot tell the diff between Eire Og and Wolfetones. It's sad that the people who are sharing this music have such disregard for the music. If you are gonna rip music to share, ffs at least get the tags right! If you have a song and you know the filename/artist/title is wrong, change it to the proper filename.
Awh well, just my 2 cents, I'll shut up now.
Christy